ValueBuddies.com : Value Investing Forum - Singapore, Hong Kong, U.S.

Full Version: Four Families and How They Tackle Rising Costs
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Four examples are given below on different households and how they tackle rising costs:-

Mar 17, 2011
THE LOWER-MIDDLE INCOME FAMILY

Saving for a home is slow going

Who: Mr Vincent Koh, 26, civil servant, and his wife Nan Myat Thu Khaing, 24, a housewife with a university degree from her native country Myanmar.

Monthly take-home income: About $3,300 (after deducting CPF)

Monthly expenses: Car loan, insurance and petrol - $1,400; mobile phone bills - $100; household expenses - $250

Monthly savings: $800 goes towards a down payment on a flat

Mr Koh and his wife are trying to save for a home of their own and move out of his parents' flat in Choa Chu Kang.

They are hoping to buy a five-room flat direct from the HDB, but saving for a down payment is slow going.

For one thing, Mr Koh's wife, who is originally from Myanmar, is on a long-term social visit pass and is not authorised to work. They registered their marriage about 10 months ago.

Ms Nan Myat Thu Khaing, who holds a university degree and is fluent in English, is applying for permanent residency so she can work and the couple can buy a subsidised HDB flat sooner.

Mr Koh's two brothers are still schooling, so he contributes towards paying for family expenses at his parents' flat. Other major household expenses include his car loan, insurance and petrol costs, which add up to about $1,400 a month.

'We usually eat at home, and might watch a movie once a week. I don't gamble, smoke or drink so there's nothing to spend on,' Mr Koh quipped.

To save money, Mr Koh tops up his fuel tank in Johor Baru, where the couple also shop for groceries and eat out occasionally.

They also wait for sales when they shop and any savings are put away for their future house.

For holidays, they wait for travel fairs and offers to nearby countries like Malaysia.

Said Mr Koh: 'My wife does most of the household shopping. She is a better finance manager than I am. She's been living here for less than a year and she's noticed that the price of most groceries has gone up.'

Tackling inflation tip... from financial planner Roy Varghese of ipac financial planning: For a couple earning less than $5,000 a month, a car is a luxury. They are better off with public transport. 'For younger people, it is essential to upgrade your skills and double your income every 10 years,' he said.

GRACE CHUA

THE MIDDLE-INCOME FAMILY
Large part of pay saved for children's education

Who: Mr Ganesan Tamilselvan, 45, runs an employment agency for technical workers and professionals. His wife, 32, also works at the agency. They have two children aged 4-1/2 and 2-1/2.

Monthly household income: About $5,000 to $6,000.

Monthly expenses: Household items and groceries about $500; insurance $150; mobile phone bills $300 (they use the phones for business and frequently make overseas calls). The monthly payment for their three-room Housing Board flat is about $750, but comes from the Central Provident Fund. They may buy furniture or appliances or repaint the flat, at $500 to $800 once a year.

Monthly savings: Children's education $1,000 a month; any remainder from spending is also saved, not spent.

With a monthly income of about $5,000 to $6,000, Mr Tamilselvan's household is solidly middle-class. The median household income for employed households here was $5,710 last year.

A large chunk of the family's income goes towards saving for their young son's and daughter's future education.

'Education is very important in Singapore; without education, life is not successful,' said Mr Tamilselvan, who has a master's degree in commerce.

When the couple bought their three-room flat about two years ago, they had just started the employment agency, and were taking home about $3,000 a month.

Although the business has taken off, they have kept to the same spending habits. They still get by without a car, taking public transport or taxis in a pinch, though Mr Tamilselvan finds himself taking taxis less to save money.

For recreation, the family goes to the beach or sightsee locally, and does not plan to take an overseas holiday soon.

They salt away their savings in fixed deposit accounts for higher interest.

Mr Tamilselvan also plans to start another business in the near future, this one importing goods from India.

However, he does not have a set retirement plan.

'I'm going to be working hard as the boss of my business... Maybe in another 15 years, I'll retire,' he said.

Tackling inflation tip... from Mr Roy Varghese of ipac financial planning: 'It is highly likely that this segment of the population will be least prepared for retirement due to a low savings rate,' he said.

But the Tamilselvan family are doing some things right, such as doing without a maid or a car.

In general, people should keep saving the same amount every month and invest in moderate risk products as a hedge against inflation. 'Working hard now is a trade-off to achieving your goals later in life,' Mr Varghese said.

GRACE CHUA

THE RETIREE
Frugal but comfortable

Who: Mr Heng Cho Choon, 67, retired teacher. His wife, 57, is an administrative officer at a private school, and plans to retire in about five years' time. They live with three sons, two of whom are working; the third is in polytechnic.

Monthly household income: $2,200 a month from pension; wife's income $2,200; $900 from an annuity which he initially paid $100,000 for when he retired 10 years ago.

Monthly expenses: Household expenses such as food, $400 a month; utilities, $300; property tax on their five-room Housing Board flat, about $100; transport, less than $100 each.

Savings: About $100,000.

Retired teacher Mr Heng says he is comfortable, but lives a simple life.

'I don't think I'm worried because I've got a pension,' he said. 'Some of my friends are relying on CPF, which is a dwindling iceberg; some have two houses and stay in one and rent out the other.'

In 2-1/2 years, his monthly pension will go up to $3,500, or two-thirds of his last drawn pay, so he is not worried about inflation. The couple also get subsidised medical care.

Still, he got rid of his car when he stopped working.

'When I was working, time was of the essence. Now, I have plenty of time so I just travel by train or bus.'

Mr Heng has a handful of hobbies: reading, writing, editing his church magazine, and photography.

However, their youngest son is still in polytechnic, and they expect to have to shell out some $50,000 for his university expenses in a few years' time.

That sum is sitting in a savings account and not earning much interest, but Mr Heng said: 'A bit of interest is also OK.'

Tackling inflation tip... from Mr James Sim, president of Financial Planning Association: Savings accounts have such low interest rates that inflation will more than wipe out any gains. Retirees should seek good advice on getting safe but steady returns on their money.

He added: 'Fighting inflation is not about saving money - when inflation comes, it is a killer of savings.'

Mr Sim said also that retirees ought to clear all remaining debt before buying any big-ticket items.

And lastly - exercise to stay healthy.

'If you are healthy, you can enjoy your retirement with a greater piece of mind.'

GRACE CHUA

THE LOW-INCOME FAMILY
Food prices are a major concern

Who: Housewife Noor Hafizah Hanafi, 29. Husband is an immigration officer and they have three kids aged 11, three, and 11 months.

Monthly household income: $1,200

Monthly expenses: Milk and diapers $600; cellphone bills $110; Household items, toiletries $80; groceries $100; transport $100; children's allowance $60; other miscellaneous expenses

Monthly savings: None

Ms Hafizah wants to work, and soon: 'I can't stay on like this. Whatever it is, I have to go out and work.'

The housewife left her sales job four years ago, before she had her second child. She said price hikes have hit the family where it matters most - at the dinner table.

Her concerns about food costs are typical of poor families as they spend a bigger chunk of their income on food. Those in the bottom 20 per cent spend about 26 per cent of their income on uncooked food and meals, compared with 18 per cent for those in the top 20 per cent, according to a 2008 household expenditure survey.

Ms Hafizah shops only once a month for groceries. She buys the cheapest variety available for essentials such as rice, milk and oil. The family eats in, almost all the time. Even after that, the Circuit Road resident sometimes saves on food items by substituting meals with instant noodles or sardines on bread.

'Are things more expensive now? Definitely,' she said.

Tackling inflation tip... from nutritionist Teo Kiok Seng: Instant noodles are all right once in a while, but try mixing white rice with unpolished rice. Also, powdered milk is cheaper than UHT milk packets. Vegetable protein, such as tempeh, tofu or even baked beans are just as good - and costs less than meat.

YEN FENG
The Low Income Family children maybe stuck in a Vicious Cycle. Definitely giving cash outright to the parent is not right thing to do.
I am sure there are many such families.

Is there an "Equal Net" today that give their kids a chance for their future to beats the odds against their generally home surrounding, parent background and education ? How much it cost to cover such group ?


Cory
(17-03-2011, 11:10 AM)corydorus Wrote: [ -> ]The Low Income Family children maybe stuck in a Vicious Cycle. Definitely giving cash outright to the parent is not right thing to do.
I am sure there are many such families.

Is there an "Equal Net" today that give their kids a chance for their future to beats the odds against their generally home surrounding, parent background and education ? How much it cost to cover such group ?


Cory

Wah, suddenly, this forum has a social work aspect to it.

My quick thoughts are that there can be no "Equal net" (if i'm understanding you interpretation of "Equal Net" correctly) Kids from advantageous backgrounds have it one up the moment they are born. No worries about going hungry, no worries about parents breaking up due to financial difficulties etc. Then add in better nutrition leading to better physical development. So no matter what can of help we give to a child from a disadvantaged background, I don't think it can equal a child born into an advantaged family.

Having said that, I think that's even more of a reason why lower income families need help. To increase the probability that a child from a lower income family attains the kind of opportunities that are available to children from the middle or even upper middle class.

As to the cost, I'm not sure. I'm not even sure how the relevant authorities are keeping track of things with all the convuluted and targeted schemes. Anyone familiar with such scenarios able to enlighten us?
That's what i meant. A Net that allow any child a good chance to beats the odds to reach Median. I will call this Singapore Dream. Tongue

"Having said that, I think that's even more of a reason why lower income families need help. To increase the probability that a child from a lower income family attains the kind of opportunities that are available to children from the middle or even upper middle class."

Ofcourse if people try to argue is in the Gene. Need to beg for. Capitalist rule. Elitist only. Then it will likely not happen.

Cory
Education helps to even out the playing field.
To break out of the poverty cycle, it takes will...lots of it.
If a child can be made to think for his/her future and work towards it, it will happen.
But because these folks do not have a mentor, it becomes a downward spiral.

For a well to do family (parents who received much education and made good), most of the time,
the child will, at the worst, be average and earn a decent living. I have seen brats being sent overseas to get their degrees,
and with proper education, it is the key to good jobs.










(19-03-2011, 02:07 AM)Big Toe Wrote: [ -> ]For a well to do family (parents who received much education and made good), most of the time,
the child will, at the worst, be average and earn a decent living. I have seen brats being sent overseas to get their degrees,
and with proper education, it is the key to good jobs.

Family connections will surely help as well. A lot of head-honchos will know you better and be more likely to offer opportunities to you if your parent is somebody rather than a farmer, dishwasher or delivery man.
Family connection is indeed immense. Therefore for families that lack of, there need to have initiatives program to get them off the financial struggle. There are so much potentials to tap from poor families younger generations if we properly develop them.

Pulling in sub-graded FT simply telling us they have taken the easy wayout like business cutting off their money losing business segment except that we are talking about real human beings. By Product of attracting Minister filling their Pocket like CEO using KPI rather than on how to uplift All Singaporean.


Cory
(19-03-2011, 11:30 AM)corydorus Wrote: [ -> ]Family connection is indeed immense. Therefore for families that lack of, there need to have initiatives program to get them off the financial struggle. There are so much potentials to tap from poor families younger generations if we properly develop them.

Pulling in sub-graded FT simply telling us they have taken the easy wayout like business cutting off their money losing business segment except that we are talking about real human beings. By Product of attracting Minister filling their Pocket like CEO using KPI rather than on how to uplift All Singaporean.


Cory

instead of pegging to top 5%, can the minister's pay peg to bottom 5%? bottom 5% move, you move...when bottom 5% move, those middle and upper move, isnt it better for all?